# Liability in AG and GmbH — when does it become personally risky?

> A corporation offers limited liability — until the day a director or managing officer breaches a duty. Anyone in a corporate function should know the five liability traps.

- Author: Viktoriia Sobiera, Sobiera Legal Consulting, Zürich
- Published: 2026-05-17
- Language: en
- Web page: https://sobiera-legal.ch/en/insights/director-liability-ag-gmbh-switzerland/
- Other language versions: [Deutsch](https://sobiera-legal.ch/de/insights/haftung-ag-gmbh-schweiz.md), [Français](https://sobiera-legal.ch/fr/insights/responsabilite-administrateur-sa-sarl-suisse.md), [Українська](https://sobiera-legal.ch/uk/insights/vidpovidalnist-ag-gmbh-shvejcariya.md), [Русский](https://sobiera-legal.ch/ru/insights/otvetstvennost-ag-gmbh-shvejcariya.md)

GmbH and AG are corporations — liability is in principle limited to the company's assets (Art. 794 and Art. 620 CO). This protection is not absolute. The corporate bodies — directors in the AG, managing officers in the GmbH — are personally liable for damages they cause through breach of duty.

Liability is detailed in the CO: Art. 754–760 CO for the AG, Art. 827 CO for the GmbH (referring to AG law). In practice, risks are highest in liquidation mandates, over-indebted companies, employment matters and tax debts.

## 1. Who is liable — definition of corporate bodies

Liability hits corporate bodies in a legal and a factual sense. A legal body is anyone registered in the commercial register as director or managing officer. A factual body is anyone who actually exercises management functions — even without registration. The Federal Supreme Court has clarified in several decisions: a 'straw-man' director is fully liable; a 'shadow management' by a majority shareholder is equally so (e.g. BGE 128 III 92).

## 2. The three (four) conditions of body liability

Under Art. 754 para. 1 CO, a corporate body is liable when the following are met:

• Breach of duty — violation of law, articles or general duty of care and loyalty.
• Damage — to the company, to shareholders or to creditors.
• Adequate causal link between breach and damage.
• Fault — the breach must be wilful or negligent.

Burden of proof: the claimant must prove all four elements. Fault, however, is presumed — the body must prove its diligence.

## 3. The five most common liability traps

### Non-payment of social-security and withholding-tax contributions

Whoever orders salary payments as a corporate body without correctly remitting AHV/IV/EO contributions and withholding tax is personally liable for the outstanding claims (Art. 52 AHVG). Liability also hits directors who are not operationally active — the duty of supervision suffices.

### Delayed notice of over-indebtedness (Art. 725 CO)

Where the board recognises that the company is over-indebted (assets no longer cover liabilities), it must notify the court — unless realistic restructuring measures and rank-subordination agreements secure the situation. Waiting too long makes the board liable to creditors for the damage caused by the delay.

### Distributions without coverage

Dividends or liquidation proceeds may flow only from distributable net profit (Art. 675 CO). Distributions without coverage harm creditors — and trigger personal liability for restitution.

### Commingling of business and private assets

Anyone treating the company as an 'extended wallet' — private expenses via the company account, lacking accounting discipline, no separation of asset pools — risks piercing the corporate veil. With sufficiently severe commingling, courts can disregard limited liability and reach the private assets.

### Breach of duty of care and loyalty (Art. 717 CO)

Directors and managing officers owe the company care and loyalty. Classic breaches: self-dealing without approval, competition with the company, accepting commissions, favouring related persons.

> In over 60 percent of liability cases before the Federal Supreme Court, the violation concerns Art. 717 CO — usually after insolvency, when the bankruptcy administrator sues on behalf of creditors.

## 4. Three avenues of action

• Action by the company (Art. 754 CO) — typically by the board or a new body after change.
• Shareholder action for performance to the company (Art. 756 CO) — derivative action.
• Creditors' action in bankruptcy (Art. 757 CO) — the bankruptcy administrator assigns the claims to creditors who can then sue.

## 5. Limitation period

Liability claims are time-barred under Art. 760 CO 5 years after knowledge of the damage, but at the latest 10 years after the breach. Where the breach is criminally relevant, criminal limitation periods apply (often 15 years).

## 6. Insurance — the D&O policy

Directors & Officers policies cover liability claims up to an agreed limit (typically CHF 5–50m). For Swiss SMEs, D&O policies are available from CHF 1,000–3,000 annual premium. What the policy does not cover: wilful breaches, fines, personal enrichment. Anyone serving in several companies should examine a 'Personal D&O' variant.

## 7. Practical tips to reduce risk

• Complete documentation of board meetings with minutes.
• Compliance with the thresholds of Art. 725 CO — quarterly equity checks, especially with growing losses.
• Clear division of responsibilities — who is in charge of what.
• Separation of business and private accounts, clean expense documentation.
• Pay social-security contributions on time; treat withholding tax as fiduciary money.
• On self-dealing: prior approval by the full board with minute entry.
• D&O insurance with sufficient limits and retroactive cover for prior mandates.

## Practical note

Sobiera Legal Consulting advises directors and managing officers on risk analysis, governance set-up and pending liability claims — in Ukrainian, Russian, German, English and French. At the first signs of over-indebtedness or an opened investigation, early advice is worthwhile — the threshold to personal liability is lower than often assumed.

---

Source: https://sobiera-legal.ch/en/insights/director-liability-ag-gmbh-switzerland/ — Sobiera Legal Consulting, Zürich. The articles are general information on Swiss law and do not replace advice on an individual case.
